Grattan: Targeted energy reforms urgently needed

Urgent action is needed to reduce the risk of power blackouts and restrictions across eastern Australia this summer, according to a new Grattan Institute report.

Powering through: how to restore confidence in the National Electricity Market says the statewide blackout in South Australia last September and a series of smaller outages and incidents over the past 18 months exposed weaknesses in the system and underscored the need for targeted reform.

The report calls for market reforms, rather than government investments in generation.

“Action must be taken. But there is an acute danger of politicians panicking and rushing to decisions that push electricity prices higher and make it harder to reduce Australia’s emissions,” a statement from authors of the report and Grattan Institute researchers Tony Wood and David Blowers said.

“New market rules would help to ensure reliable supply when something in the system breaks.

“And regulators should use their existing powers to recall to service some mothballed generators to ensure reserves are on hand in an emergency, even if that increases costs a little in the short run.”

Greater effort is needed to ensure efficient responses to shortages in generation, according to the report, and power generators should be rewarded for being flexible and responding quickly.

The report also suggests customers should be offered a financial incentive to relieve stress on the system by limiting the amount of electricity they use during peak times.

“A decade of toxic political debates, mixed messages and policy backflips has prevented the emergence of credible climate change policy,” Mr Wood said.

“Investment in electricity generation, including renewables, is stalling as market participants await clear policy signals from government.

“Knee-jerk policy responses to the electricity market crisis, such as the Federal Government’s Snowy Hydro 2.0 scheme and the South Australian Government’s go-it-alone power plan, risk destroying the NEM’s capacity to drive the new investment Australia needs for low-cost, reliable and low-emissions electricity.

“If that happens, the NEM will be judged to have failed. But in fact, policy decisions will have systematically, if unintentionally, destroyed it.

“The survival of the NEM cannot be assumed. But we should not give up on the market.

“If governments take matters fully into their own hands, the results are likely to be painful: customers will pay more for their electricity, supply could become even less reliable, and Australia still may not reduce emissions as we have promised.”

AusNet Services managing director Nino Ficca said the report was a balanced analysis of the current energy challenges and provided considered solutions.

“Short-term focused partisan politics has no place in the energy debate,” Mr Ficca said.

“The energy sector faces some major challenges, but if we continue to see partisan politics on climate change, energy security and affordability things will get worse not better.

“If states put their own short-term political needs ahead of national interests, over the long term it will be harder to avoid blackouts and higher electricity prices for consumers.”